Looking for:
Logic pro x vs ableton reddit free - |
Logic Pro vs Ableton: Which is The Better DAW? - Guitar Space.Products - Whole Loops
This may seem like a time consuming process but choosing the correct DAW is a decision that you will carry throughout your entire music career so a few weeks spent making the right decision now may shave years off of how long it takes you to break through as an artist in the future.
Furthermore it may save you from having to transition to a different DAW in a few years time if you made the wrong choice when you first started producing. Is it okay to use both? Of course, it is, but keep in mind that it will take a considerable amount of time to become completely fluent in both programmes and know which one to use in to scenarios. This time may be better spent completely honing your skills in just one of the applications and focusing your spare time on pushing your career as an artist forward.
Try the 30 day free trial of Ableton Live 10 Suite here. Try out the Garage Band Lite version of Logic here. IV Vintage Drum Machines. Skip to the YouTube video instead. Watch Video. Ableton Push 2 Get it here. Both applications have been very careful to ensure that they can run with very low CPU usage and they have also added ways for the user to reduce CPU manually by disabling certain features which are not often used or required.
It also goes without saying to remove or turn off any devices not being used. Quick View. Add to basket. Ableton Live Keyboard Overlay Get it here. Ableton Live used for Live Performance. Logic Remote. Logic Pro's legacy compressor compared to the new compressor interface. Garage Band Apples lite version of Logic Pro. Free Plugin — Rave Generator 2 from Wavosaur. Logic Pro has a single version and can be found here.
Ableton has done an excellent job of keeping this crucial element of the system clutter-free. Live is an example in this regard.
Before Logic Pro X That sharpness has been dulled now that Logic Pro X has its own well-thought-out and tightly integrated take on the same notion in the form of the Live Loops Grid. The winner of the audio recording section is Logic Pro. However, many Live users spend most of their time creating music in the Arrangement View, which is excellently served by its nimble navigation, quick UI, seamless automation, and generally obstacle-free approach.
Section-defining Arrangement Markers, scissors, glue, erase. In practice, though, linear music arrangement in any DAW is a delight. The winner of the linear arrangement in Logic Pro. The groundbreaking non-linear Session View clip recording and launching interface from Ableton Live took a few years to alter the world of music technology. Still, it established the de facto standard for laptop DJing and dance music creation and placed the Berlin-based business on the map.
This apparently benign Clip View control panel allows producers and live performers to automate and randomize clip-launching within Scenes, something no other DAW can accomplish. The winner of the loop arrangement is Ableton. Alchemy is the most obviously powerful of the two, taking in additive, granular, and analog-style synthesis, with four simultaneous inputs, gobs of filters, and abundant effects.
It was formerly an expensive third-party instrument until Apple purchased its developer, Camel Audio. On the other hand, wavetable is a two-oscillator plus sub wavetable synth with over well-crafted wavetables onboard, two filters, extensive modulation possibilities, and an extremely user-friendly interface and workflow.
Each DAW has their own separate learning curve. Some offer a more linear, beginner-friendly interface, while others definitely take some time to get used to. To help out beginners and often even advanced producers both Ableton and Logic Pro offer on-board explanations of each control and production module. In Ableton, simply hover your mouse over something and a brief description will appear in the bottom left corner of the screen. From my experience, producers with no prior knowledge of music creation seem to pick up Logic way faster than almost any other DAW.
This seems to be primarily down to the spacious, clear layout and module arrangement. The developers clearly put a enormous amount of effort into the spacial design, making it not only highly intuitive, but rapid and responsive. One example here is loop-based production. Ableton is one of the fastest, most practical DAWs out there. Furthermore, you can optimise almost anything according to your unique workflow. Ableton Live 10 currently comes with 17 instruments and 59 audio effects.
This is your zoom tool so you can zoom in and out and make edits accordingly to your clips. Hovering your mouse just under the time ruler will result in a speaker icon, allowing you to click and play from that point in time. Placing your mouse at the edge of a clip will activate trimming, clicking in the area above the waveform will bring up a hand and allow you to move clips around, and clicking in the waveform area itself will let you make selections to cut audio and move it around accordingly.
Fades show up when you reach a certain zoom level and have UI for curves and fade length. Create Fades on Clip Edges is a preference you can turn on and off in the preferences and comes in handy for saving time when editing audio. The key differences in the edit window of each DAW make for very different workflows. Key command users would prefer Logic Pro X, and appreciators of the what-you-see-is-what-get variety, Ableton Live excels. Ableton has an immensely useful collection of MIDI instruments, such as the extremely versatile and user-friendly, Wavetable Synth.
With 2 oscillators, it's not overpowering, yet it has a wide variety of wavetables to choose from, the routing matrix is easy to get used to, and the tonality can closely resemble an analog synth. Live also has an equally as powerful midi environment. MIDI data can be entered using the qwerty keyboard by enabling the keyboard icon in the top right. Just turn it on and your keyboard is not able to send MIDI signals.
As with the changing mouse tool in the arrange view, most things in Live are right there in front of you and do not require key commands or sub-menus. Editing using the piano roll is quick and often activated like every digital audio workstation, by simply clicking the MIDI clip. Logic Pro's process is more or less identical. Slim to zero sub-menus are contained and interesting sounds come are conjured up in an instant while creating organic sounding music.
Logic's long development history has made it a MIDI titan in the digital world. Ableton Live does pale in comparison to it. For starters, the toolset is greater and, because key commands can be used, is much snappier once you get used to them. Also, the event list editor displays handy inspector-based MIDI in an easy-to-read manner, allowing you to edit all of the MIDI data that's been entered.
MIDI editing can become quite a granular process if you'd like it to be. Recording MIDI loops in Logic Pro X has its own set of features, in which you can choose between creating a folder of takes to later comb through and comp, merging all the takes into a single MIDI file, overlap notes, a combination of overlapping and merging, or creating a completely new track.
Logic may have my favorite DAW-based drum sequencer. However, Logic's retro synth, Ultrabeat drum machine, though slightly old in its UI design, is an incredible piece of music technology.
As one of the most trusted MIDI stock plugins Logic has to offer, it has withstood the test of time from a functionality standpoint. A full kit contains 25 MIDI voices, the 25th moving up a chromatic scale, becoming a nice bonus sampler, and potentially one less sampler track that you'll need in your session, saving another MIDI voice.
Users who are comfortable with performing with an iPad will surely appreciate the usability and portability of the remote app. Good old-fashioned button pushers and knob twisters may want something a little more tangible. I think it's safe to say that Ableton Live takes the cake for controller integration. The Push 2 integrates into Ableton so much so, that you don't even have to touch the computer at all when you're using it. You can move through menus, select sounds, instruments, warp, slice to 64 pads, play chords, scales, modes, make MIDI loops, and launch clips.
If you're looking to perform live with a controller specifically and are trying to decide between Ableton Live vs. Logic Pro, trust the namesake. When it comes to audio recording, Logic Pro X is equipped with enough features to execute both small format and large format projects. Whether you're at home using your live instruments, or in a professional recording studio executing a multitrack recording of a player brass band, Logic Pro X is an effective tool. Live performers will also appreciate the low latency mode it has so that they can record with a very minimal delay so as not to get distracted while overdubbing.
Grouping, an age-old recording concept, has also been enhanced by Logic Pro X. If you need to send multiple sources to one place, i. You can also choose whether you'd like to sub-mix them or simply make folders for organizational purposes during your mix.
Since around Logic For music, you'd be hard-pressed to use that many, but you never know. If you do get to the point where your system is starting to become sluggish due to high DSP usage, you can initiate CPU-saving track freezing.
Compare Live editions | Ableton - MIDI: Editing, Effects, Software Instruments, Controllers
Making the switch from one DAW to another can be tricky too. Ableton for your main DAW. So which one should you choose? What do you need to know to decide and what does it take to learn?
While it may seem like there are huge differences from one to the next, many of the core functions are the same between programs. Not only that, many producers learn more than one DAW to stay flexible for different projects and collaborators.
Workflow means the basic process of building tracks in a DAW. There are plenty of different approaches that vary by genre and personal style. On the surface, the single biggest workflow difference between Logic and Ableton is the loop-based sequencing environment in Live called the Session view.
On the surface, the single biggest workflow difference between Logic and Ableton lies in the loop-based sequencing environment in Live called the Session view. Instead of a traditional left-to-right timeline, Session view lets you quickly capture loops and arrange them into patterns and sequences. Clips in the Session view have their own powerful pane of controls—including the famous Warp function that allows you to manipulate tempo and pitch. If you work with virtual instruments , loops or existing audio, you might find this approach faster and more flexible for creating tracks.
While Apple has debuted a loop-based view in the latest release of Logic Pro, it still feels more traditional overall. For example, the Logic Pro mixer offers a more familiar experience for mixing full songs with features like configurable buses and per-channel EQ. On top of that, you may find traditional timeline operations like level automation easier to perform in Logic. Hot tip : Previous versions of Live lacked staple recording features such as groups and comping.
Ableton introduced great versions of these essential tracking tools in the new Live But Logic offers deep MIDI editing capabilities that can be helpful for programming expressive parts. Its piano roll editor is sophisticated but not too complex for beginners to jump in and get started.
On top of that, Logic includes a powerful notation editor that can turn MIDI parts into written music quickly and accurately. Simply click the MIDI Learn icon, select any parameter and move any knob, button or slider on your controller—Ableton will map it automatically!
Their signature look and feel also makes these instruments some of the easiest to use, even for beginners. Ableton Live is well known for its producer-friendly effects and great instruments. For example, Flex Time and Flex Pitch offer audio editing capabilities that typically come with paid software like AutoTune. They can be a lifesaver when it comes to vocal pitch correction and rhythm editing. Logic also comes standard with several virtual instruments built to emulate studio favorites.
Rounded out with the the flexible character compressor and new vintage EQ collection, Logic offers a complete set of tools right out of the box. Both Ableton Live 11 and Logic Pro feature the ability to add a video to the session. This is especially useful for creating soundtrack music or re-editing tracks for sync licensing. Apple is betting big on spatial audio with the introduction of Atmos to Apple Music in Live is a bit more limited in this respect, but Ableton recently released a Surround Panner device for their Max for Live modular environment more on that in a second that helps for mixing in these formats.
Max for Live is an edition of the software built to run inside Live. Even with the high price, Live is still worth every penny. However, Logic Pro is cheaper overall. Hot tip : Many beginner and intermediate music production products come bundled with an introductory version of Live.
Ableton works just as well on either platform, so it might be high on your list if you use a PC for production. When it comes to hardware, Ableton has a handful of specialized controllers that have been developed to let you go hands-on with all its features. It was built by the Ableton team to be the perfect hands-on companion to Live. Hot tip : Although Live is known for its use in performances, Mainstage is the companion app to Logic that many musicians use as a VST host to perform live.
Check out our VST Host breakdown to see how this type of app functions in a live setting. In the end, any DAW you choose is a great start, even if you have to make a change down the road. Skip to primary navigation Skip to main content. Logic vs.
Workflow Workflow means the basic process of building tracks in a DAW. This lends itself especially well to playing…live…which is a big benefit to choosing Ableton. Price While features and workflow are certainly important, cost is a big factor at the end of the day.
While features and workflow are certainly important, cost is a big factor at the end of the day. Hardware Finally, there are a few hardware issues to consider as you decide between Logic and Ableton.
You'll like that too. Music Gear.
No comments:
Post a Comment